Commercial vs. Industrial Property in Singapore: 8 Key Considerations for Investors

In our previous article, about commercial and industrial properties, we covered the main differences between the 2 types of properties and investing tips when it comes to choosing the right property for you.

In this article, we are going to dive deeper into the financial considerations when it comes to commercial vs industrial properties so that you can make the right investment choice for your financial goals and risk tolerance.

1) Investment Objectives and Risk Tolerance

Every investor approaches the market with different goals and varying levels of risk tolerance. Commercial properties, such as office spaces and retail outlets, tend to attract investors seeking stable rental income and long-term value growth. These properties benefit from high visibility and accessibility, which can drive consistent rental demand. However, they may require more hands-on management and can be more susceptible to economic downturns.

In contrast, industrial properties often appeal to those pursuing higher yields and facing less competition. These properties typically have longer lease durations and can offer a reliable income stream. However, they come with unique risks, such as the cyclical nature of industrial sectors and shorter lease tenures.

2) Target Market Differences: Businesses vs. Individuals

A fundamental difference between commercial and industrial properties is the nature of their target markets. 

Commercial properties are typically rented by businesses that provide services, such as offices, retail outlets, and hospitality venues. These properties are often located in areas with high foot traffic and depend on a steady flow of consumers to maintain rental demand. On the other hand, industrial properties cater to businesses focused on manufacturing, logistics, and production activities, where tenants seek operational space for warehousing, factories, and production lines.

Industrial properties: the tenant base is generally more stable, as these spaces are essential for daily operations. However, the tenant pool for commercial properties may fluctuate based on market demand, especially during economic downturns when businesses might downsize or close. This means that investors need to consider the economic resilience of their target market when choosing between commercial and industrial properties.

3) Financial Factors to Consider

Properly understanding the financial aspects is crucial for successful property investment:

• GST and ABSD: While commercial properties in Singapore are subject to Goods and Services Tax (GST), they are exempt from Additional Buyer’s Stamp Duty (ABSD), which can make them an attractive option for investors. For industrial properties, GST may also apply, but no ABSD is required, providing another avenue for portfolio diversification.

• Loan-to-Value (LTV) and Total Debt Servicing Ratio (TDSR): The LTV ratio for commercial and industrial properties is generally lower than that for residential properties, meaning a larger initial capital investment is required. Additionally, the TDSR framework ensures that your total monthly debt repayments do not exceed a certain percentage of your income, which applies to both property types.

4) Impact of Economic Fluctuations

One of the most important factors to consider when investing in commercial or industrial properties is how they perform during economic fluctuations. 

Commercial Properties: Demand for commercial spaces, especially offices and retail outlets, is closely tied to the economic landscape and sector growth, including tourism and retail. While the COVID-19 pandemic severely impacted these sectors, the gradual recovery driven by the resumption of international travel and business activities offers positive signs for future growth.

Industrial Properties: These properties are more influenced by the health of the manufacturing sector, government regulations on industrial land, and global trade trends. As Singapore positions itself as a leader in high-tech manufacturing, the demand for specialized industrial spaces is expected to rise.

5) Financing and Mortgage Considerations

Financing is a critical aspect of any property investment, and the ability to secure favorable terms can significantly impact an investor's cash flow and profitability. When investing in commercial or industrial properties, one key difference is that mortgage repayments must be made in cash. Investors cannot use CPF (Central Provident Fund) savings to pay off the mortgage, unlike in residential property investments. This makes cash flow management crucial, as investors need to ensure they have enough liquidity to cover mortgage payments, especially during periods of vacancy or economic slowdown.

Additionally, the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio for commercial and industrial properties is typically lower than that for residential properties, meaning investors may need a higher upfront capital outlay. Investors should carefully assess their financial capacity before committing to a commercial or industrial property investment.

6) Differences in Lease Terms

Lease terms also differ significantly between commercial and industrial properties. In Singapore, 

Commercial Properties: Often come with longer lease terms, typically 99 years. This extended lease tenure can provide greater stability for investors looking for long-term capital appreciation and rental income. There are also properties that comes with 999 years or freehold tenure.

Industrial properties: Usually have shorter lease durations, ranging from 30 to 60 years. While these properties may offer higher rental yields, the shorter lease period can limit the potential for capital appreciation and resale value. Investors need to factor in the remaining lease tenure when considering an industrial property purchase, as it may impact both the long-term value and marketability of the asset. There are also properties that comes with 999 years or freehold tenure.

7) Government Regulations and Zoning

Zoning laws and government regulations play a crucial role in shaping the availability and use of commercial and industrial properties in Singapore. 

Commercial properties: Particularly those located in high-traffic areas like the Central Business District (CBD), are subject to different regulations focused on ensuring accessibility and maintaining business-friendly environments. Understanding these zoning regulations is essential for investors, as they can affect the potential uses of the property and the types of tenants that can be attracted.

Industrial properties: Subject to strict zoning requirements, which determine the types of activities that can take place on-site. For example, B1 zones allow for light industrial activities with minimal environmental impact, such as clean manufacturing or warehousing, while B2 zones are designated for heavier industrial activities like manufacturing and construction, which may generate noise and pollution.

8) Higher Rental Yields in Industrial Properties

One key advantage of investing in industrial properties is the potential for higher rental yields compared to commercial properties. Many businesses, particularly in sectors like logistics and manufacturing, require large amounts of operational space and are willing to pay higher rents for functional and well-located industrial facilities. Additionally, industrial properties often have longer leases with stable tenants, providing consistent rental income.

Commercial properties, while often located in more prestigious areas, may have lower rental yields due to higher vacancy rates and shorter lease terms. However, commercial properties tend to offer better opportunities for capital appreciation, especially if they are located in high-demand business districts.

Conclusion

Investing in commercial and industrial properties in Singapore presents a range of opportunities for both seasoned and first-time investors. While both asset classes offer the potential for rental income and capital appreciation, understanding their key differences—such as target markets, economic resilience, financing options, lease terms, and zoning regulations—is critical for making informed decisions.

Investors looking for stability and higher rental yields may find industrial properties more appealing, while those seeking long-term capital growth may prefer commercial properties in prime locations. As always, conducting thorough research and consulting with property experts will help ensure that your investment aligns with your financial goals and risk appetite.

Whether you're considering a commercial or industrial property investment, it's essential to stay informed about the latest market trends and regulatory changes. With the right strategy and insights, both types of properties can provide lucrative returns in Singapore's dynamic real estate landscape.

Meanwhile we have a couple of commercial offices and retail spaces in the CBD for sale.  Prices are from as low as $830k onwards.  Do contact us for more info

Contact Us Via WhatsApp